Not all antler chews are the same — and that’s a good thing. Dogs chew for different reasons and with different intensity levels, so the ideal antler for a teething puppy isn’t the same as the best pick for a determined power chewer. This quick guide shows you how to match type and size to your dog’s chewing style so they get a satisfying, safe, natural chew.
Step 1 — Identify Your Dog’s Chewing Style
Puppy
Teething pups want taste and texture without excessive hardness. Look for easier marrow access. Even though puppies love to chew, we suggest only the softest chews.
Light Chewer
Picky chewers, smaller breeds, and seniors who prefer to lick and lightly gnaw. They enjoy marrow and easy chewing.
Moderate Chewer
The everyday chewer: enjoys regular sessions and appreciates a balance of toughness and reward. Most adult dogs fall here.
Strong Chewer
Determined, jaw-power dogs who put chews to the test. They need dense cuts that stand up to heavy grinding and last longer.
Step 2 — Match the Antler Type to the Chewer
Antlers vary by species and cut. Here’s how to pick:
Puppy & Light Chewers
- Split Antlers (Elk or Deer): Easy marrow access, more reward with less effort.
- Moose Paddles: Broad, flatter surface with plenty of marrow — also an easier chew (select low or medium density moose).
Moderate Chewers
- Whole Elk: Durable outer layer with rewarding marrow core — the “sweet spot” for many dogs.
- Deer Sections: A bit denser; great for dogs who like a firm chew but don’t need the toughest cut.
Strong Chewers
- Dense Whole Elk & Deer Base: Heavier, thicker sections for maximum durability.
- Select Moose Tines: Tougher shapes that offer long-lasting challenge.
All antler chews always ship FREE.
Step 3 — Pick the Right Size
Size matters as much as type. As a rule, bigger is safer and lasts longer. Choose a piece large enough that your dog can’t fit the whole chew behind the molars at once. If your dog is between sizes, size up.
Not sure which weight or length to choose? See our quick sizing advice here: Antler Guide →
Safety & Care Tips
- Supervise chewing, especially with new chews or puppies.
- Replace the antler when it becomes small enough to swallow.
- Air-dry between sessions; keep chews cool and dry between uses.
- For dehydrated treats and toppers (not antlers), see our Storage Guide for freshness and safety.
Why Antlers from Chewy Pawz?
- Naturally shed & single-ingredient: No chemicals, dyes, or preservatives.
- Ethically sourced in the USA: Hand-processed in Wyoming.
- Options for every chewer: From split paddles to dense whole base sections.
- Free shipping on all antler chews — always.
